In a unanimous decision, the U.S. Supreme Court has upheld a church’s right under the First Amendment to fire an employee who was a minister despite federal antidiscrimination laws. The case, Hosanna-Tabor Evangelical Lutheran Church and School v. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, marks the first time the Supreme Court has recognized the First Amendment-based ministerial exception to antidiscrimination laws. Federal appeals courts had recognized the exception but not the high court — until now. The exception is rooted in the First Amendment’s protection of religious freedom and ensures that churches and other religious groups can choose their own ministers as they see fit.
The case involved Cheryl Perich, a teacher employed by a congregation of the Lutheran Church — Missouri Synod at its church school. The school employed two classes of teachers: (1) “called” teachers, who completed a course of religious study and attained the title of “minister of religion, commissioned,” and (2) lay teachers, who had no religious training and moreover didn’t have to be Lutheran. Perich, as a called teacher, taught a religion class, led students in daily prayer, took them to chapel services, occasionally led chapel services, and taught secular subjects.
read more…